ACHIEVING CRITICAL TRANSFORMATION IN UNDERGRADUATE PROGRAMS OF MATHEMATICS

ACT UP Math

math equation on chalkboard next to notepad and calculator

Overview

The disparities in achievement and access for marginalized students are well documented, but there remains a lack of attention to what to do with this knowledge and how to measure the impact of improvement efforts beyond pass rates and demographics. While many university mathematics departments value providing diverse, equitable, and inclusive (DEI) student experiences, the faculty often do not have the professional training to engage with DEI work or measure its progress, which can lead to disengagement from these initiatives.

ACT UP (a $1.5 million grant from the National Science Foundation) aims to conduct foundational research to identify the mechanisms and structures that best support mathematics stakeholders in making data-informed decisions to promote DEI and critically transform introductory mathematics courses and programs. This project builds on the strength of two prior national studies of introductory mathematics programs, Progress through Calculus and Student Engagement in Mathematics through an Institutional Network for Active Learning (SEMINAL). Three undergraduate mathematics department teams will work in partnership with educational researchers to analyze their local data, in comparison to the national sample.

In partnership with: California State University East Bay, Clemson University, Colorado State University, Duke University, and Kennesaw State University

Goals

1

Conducting basic, use-inspired foundational research related to departments’ use of data in their equity work with the goal of shifting the focus from strictly student outcomes to also include consideration of students’ lived experiences in introductory mathematics courses, leading to critical transformations.

2

Studying the enactment of networked improvement communities involving educational researchers and mathematics department stakeholders, aiming to increase the effectiveness and impact of mathematics departments’ uses of data to improve diversity, equity and inclusion.

3

Interrogating the mechanisms underlying data-informed decision-making with key mathematics department stakeholders to critically address topics and issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion in their introductory mathematics programs.

STEM stakeholders are aware of the differences in mathematics outcomes among students of different races, socio-economic statuses, genders, and other identities, and stakeholders need support to develop more nuanced understandings of the factors contributing to these differences and to translate their understanding into action.

Cited Work

Workshops

Funk, R. & Quaisley, K. (upcoming, 2024, March). Using institutional data to guide efforts toward equity and inclusion [workshop]. MAA MSI Leadership Summit 2024.

Journal Articles

Bolick, M.A., & Voigt, M. (2023). Using Interactive Data Dashboards to Address Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Introductory Math Programs. MAA Focus, 43(6), 14-17. Retrieved from: http://digitaleditions.walsworthprintgroup.com/publication/?m=7656&i=809747&p=14&ver=html5

Presentations

Bennett, A. B., Funk, R., & Smith, W. M. (2023, September). ACT UP Math: Critical approaches. Presentation to the Mathematics Education Doctoral Seminar, University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Lincoln, Nebraska and online.

Hagman, J.E., (2023, October). Supporting Equity Through Coordination in Calculus: Balancing Fairness with Justice, Department of Mathematics Education, Cal Poly Pomona.

Smith, W. M. (September, 2023). Chairs and Directors Workshop: Leading Department Change to Improve Teaching and Learning. Invited presentation to the University of Nebraska-Lincoln's College of Arts and Sciences chairs and directors.

Smith, W. M. (October, 2023). Partnerships for change: Disrupting historical power dynamics to transform STEM teaching and learning. Presentation to the Clemson Seminar in Engineering and Science Education, online.

Smith, W. M. (November, 2023). Research on partnerships to support transfer students. Invited presentation to the annual conference of the American Mathematical Association of Two Year Colleges (AMATYC), Omaha, Nebraska.

Tremaine, R. (2023, October). Exploring motives for equity reform in undergraduate mathematics education. Presentation to the Mathematics Education Doctoral Seminar, University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Lincoln, Nebraska and online.

Voigt, M. (2023, Sept.) Engaging in Critical Transformation of Math Programs to Disrupt the System. [Invited Speaker] Teaching and Learning Seminar, Department of Mathematics. North Carolina State University: Charlotte, NC

Participating Sites

CSU Logo

California State University East Bay

CSU East Bay is a public Master’s degree-granting university with moderate research activity and is one of the most diverse higher education institutions among the participating SEMINALsites.

Local Leaders

  • Simone Sisneros-Thiry
  • Julia Olkin
  • Andrea Arauza Rivera
duke university logo

Duke University

Duke University is a private not-for-profit highly-selective doctoral degree-granting university that is research-intensive, located in North Carolina. Introductory math courses at Duke are taught primarily in large courses taught by teaching faculty with a group-work focused recitation once a week led by a graduate teaching assistant.

Local Leaders

  • Tori Akin
  • Shira Viel
  • Maria Tackett
Kennesaw state logo

Kennesaw State University

Kennesaw State University is a public, doctoral degree-granting, comprehensive university with an R2 Carnegie classification located in Georgia. As a participating SEMINAL site, most math courses are taught in small classes with some faculty using active learning strategies.

Local Leaders

  • Kadian Callahan
  • Benjamin Sloop
  • Katie Christensen

Research Team

Principal Investigators

Wendy Smith

University of Nebraska-Lincoln
wsmith5@unl.edu

Principal Investigator

Wendy Smith Portrait

Matt Voigt

Clemson University
mkvoigt@clemson.edu

Principal Investigator

matt voigt portrait

Jess Ellis Hagman

Colorado State University
jess.ellis@colostate.edu

Principal Investigator

jess ellis

Nancy Kress

University of Colorado Boulder
Nancy.Kress@colorado.edu

Principal Investigator

Nancy kress portrait

Kadian Callahan

Kennesaw State University
kcallah6@kennesaw.edu

Principal Investigator

kadian Callahan portrait

Tori Akin

Duke University

victoria.akin@duke.edu

Senior Personnel

Tori Akin

Amy Bennett

University of Nebraska-Lincoln

abennett14@unl.edu

Senior Personnel

Amy Bennett

Katie Christensen

Kennesaw State University

kchris53@kennesaw.edu

Senior Personnel

 Katie Christensen

Julia Olkin

California State University East Bay

Julia.olkin@csueastbay.edu

Senior Personnel

Julia Olkin

Simone Sisneros-Thiry

California State University East Bay

simone.sisnerosthiry@csueastbay.edu

Senior Personnel

 Simone Sisneros-Thiry

Benjamin Sloop

Kennesaw State University

bsloop@kennesaw.edu

Senior Personnel

Benjamin Sloop

Maria Tackett

Duke University

maria.tackett@duke.edu

Senior Personnel

Maria Tackett

Shira Viel

Duke University

viel@math.duke.edu

Senior Personnel

Shira Viel

Trish Wonch Hill

University of Nebraska-Lincoln

phill3@unl.edu

Senior Personnel

Trish Wonch Hill

Rachel Funk

University of Nebraska-Lincoln

rachel.funk@unl.edu

Project Manager and Research Scientist

Rachel Funk

Margaret Ann Bolick

Clemson University

bolick4@g.clemson.edu

Graduate Research Associate

Margaret Ann Bolick

Abbey D'Ovidio Long

University of Nebraska-Lincoln

along19@huskers.unl.edu

Graduate Research Associate

Abbey D'Ovidio Long

Kaylee Fantin-Hardesty

Colorado State University

kaylee.fantinhardesty@colostate.edu

Graduate Research Associate

Kelsey Quaisley

University of Nebraska-Lincoln

kquigley@huskers.unl.edu

Graduate Research Associate

Kelsey Quaisley

Rachel Tremaine

Colorado State University

tremainecsu@gmail.com

Graduate Research Associate

External Advisor

Dr. Chris Jett is our external advisor, serving as a critical friend to help center and strengthen our implementation of criticality.

Chris Jett

Georgia State University

Associate Professor

Chris Jett